Art Appropriate

Art-Appropriate Sophia, a high school senior, visits an art fair hosting artists from diverse backgrounds and art that represents a wide range of cultures. She stumbles upon a captivating painting depicting a Native American burial site. The artwork is rich with symbolism, hinting at themes of life after death, spirituality, and the interconnectedness of all living things—concepts that resonate with Sophia's own musings about humanity and existence.   Enthralled by the painting's beauty and the themes it embodies, Sophia decides to purchase it to hang in her room. She believes the piece not only enhances her personal space but also serves as a profound reminder of the shared human experiences across different cultures. However, when Sophia shares a photo of the painting on social media, the responses are mixed. Some friends admire her taste, while others raise concerns. One comment reads, "Is it appropriate to display sacred symbols from a culture that isn't yours?" Another friend adds, "Art is universal, and appreciating it is a way of honoring the culture. How else are we supposed to learn?”   Sophia hadn't considered that the burial site might hold significant spiritual importance exclusive to Native American communities. She begins to wonder if her admiration crosses into appropriation. Determined to understand the implications, she researches the origins of the painting and the artist. She learns that the artist is not of Native American descent but was inspired by a visit to historical sites in the Southwest. This discovery causes her to raise questions about whether it was appropriate for the artist to depict this in the first place and whether her purchase is contributing to a commodification of cultural traditions. Sophia contemplates her next steps; what if anything should she do?

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

1.Is Sophia's decision to purchase and display the painting an act of cultural appreciation or cultural appropriation?

2.What factors determine whether engaging with another culture's art is respectful or appropriative?

3.Does an artist's lack of heritage affect the ethical considerations when creating, selling, or buying art from a specific culture?

4.What is the role of intent versus impact when it comes to cultural appropriation in art?